Mastering Crisis Management with Kate Gardiner
- Show
- The Elite Entrepreneurs Podcast
- Air date
This is an unedited transcript and may contain errors.
Everyone, welcome to the Seven Figure Journey podcast. I'm one of your hosts, Joel, today. And today we're interviewing Kate from Grey Horse. And I'm super excited to have her. She has some really cool things that she's been working on for about a decade. You know, super high level people, you know, doing some really good things in this world about women, people of color, and we're both going to get to learn more about what she does and this is going to be fun.
Kate, why don't you introduce yourself a bit? Sure. So I'm Kate Gardiner. I'm the CEO and founder of Grey Horse. We're a full service communications agency that works at the intersection of crisis communications and the public. We do three main things.
One is traditional public relations. The second is events and producing events, conversations, dinners, conferences, all sorts of things along those lines. And then the third thing is crisis communications, which is the bulk of our business. It's the challenging situation where you intervene in a developing scenario that may be controversial in public and figure out the best means forward. We very much do this in partnership with litigators. We do this in partnership with public figures.
And of course, we do this for companies who find themselves suddenly at the center of attention for some sort of public spectacle. We've done this in the context of diversity, equality, and inclusion. We've done this in the context of women's rights and sexual assault. And of course, we've done this in the context of criminal activities that have reflected poorly on anything, but you never know what's next. That's the fun part about doing this business. Honestly, for me personally, I'm always the type person that wants to soak up information.
I know that a lot of your clients are confidential. You're not going to be able to talk details about any specific stories, but maybe you could give like genesis, management, pretty much agency part. Curious. So obviously we see crisis like every day, you know, the news, celebrities, this or that. There's like an everyday thing. You go on Instagram and you see this happened to this person, etc.
And so from what I'm gathering is like you play a key role with certain elements. I guess people come to you of high net worth and how to properly navigate those situations. What's your typical process look like when you got somebody, let's say celebrity status or somebody who's in the public eye that comes to you with a crisis? I know you said you already work with litigators, but what does that process look like? Yeah. So the first thing that we do is to be onboarded by either the individual who's most dramatically affected or someone who cares for them.
And that's typically someone in a business relationship who cares for their assets or cares for their personal brand. This could be your public relations team. It could be your attorney. And it can, of course, be your accountant or other money manager type person. And in these circumstances, sometimes we know that something's coming. So for example, if someone's filed a lawsuit against you or has given you notice that they intend to do so, we will come up with an action plan related to that lawsuit.
In other circumstances, sometimes we wake up and our name is all over the internet. Best course of action is given those circumstances. This can happen because, for example, you posted something online that didn't go well or went too well, or you are the subject of scrutiny in some way. We have a lot of intergenerational conflicts. We have a lot of different types of conflicts between individuals these days. And all of those scenarios can merit a special response.
The smallest things I've responded to tend to be sort of local and dramatic. PTA battles, for example. The larger things you've definitely seen our work on various public, very public hashtags. And sometimes we are at the beginning of those hashtags and sometimes we're participating in them. But most of the time, it's a public figure who wants to take action in some way about the circumstances they find themselves in. And our process goes from this initial onboarding, which is usually within 24 hours of the lawsuit notification, for example, or the viral moment, all the way through sort of an 18 month cycle where we're trying to either rebuild the person's reputation or otherwise engage with the person's reputation in a more positive way.
And sometimes that's more possible than others, but we do the best that we can given the circumstances that have come up, you know, to make the person or people happier, uh, all things considered. What comes to my mind or I'm curious, what what type of team does it take to put together a service like this, apart from, you know, litigate litigator? Yeah, so we have me and one other person tend to lead the crisis communications responses, um, and then we have a team of folks who do all sorts of different things depending on the circumstances. Um, every single crisis is different to use an opportunity to build their followers. And those things really just depend. Uh, there is, uh, an overarching goal amongst most people, uh, to spin things into a positive direction, um, and we try to do that whenever it's possible.
Uh, but, you know, it's always an adventure. I can't always predict what the public response to something is going to be. We also intercede a lot with the media, so we will redirect, uh, the media attention in a way that we prefer. Uh, that doesn't always work, but it does work most of the time, uh, particularly if we're able to guide the media reporter or whoever, uh, in a more positive direction for the client. Seems like a very interesting field of work, honestly. It's pretty cool.
I'm curious to know what got you started and and wanted to do this, you know, like what what that what that what's that founding story? Sure. So I How did we get here? Yeah, so I was a journalist. Um, you can Google and dig really deep and eventually you'll find me on air. Um, but, uh, I was a journalist for many years and then I was an executive of sorts for media.
Um, and in all of those circumstances, much of what I was doing would explode and it would be all over the media. And that was kind of the point of hiring me for many years. And so when I pivoted and I started doing it for crisis communications, it was in part because media is really struggling right now to take advantage of this new era of of content creation. Um, and it's, uh, it's quite the adventure, uh, trying to figure out how, uh, to find a path forward using all of these new tools and recognizing that, uh, content is no longer siloed, content is no longer as edited or controlled as it used to be. Uh, and the concept of news generation has really, really changed. Um, and there was just an opportunity to start doing that.
We actually started with social media first, so we mostly were doing social media related crisis communications, um, but we've really branched out in the past few years, um, particularly because some, uh, we've been in the right place at the right time. But throughout my reporting career, I also was in the right place at the right time if sort of, um, and I just ended up having disasters following me every time I switched news organizations. Um, and so ultimately all those skills really are only transferable to like hugely fast-paced situations, uh, which has kind of become our specialty. Now with just carry on. A little bit from the major topic, which is like leadership fatigue, but I'm just curious like so you know, yeah, we have all these big media companies, right? You know, but as we as we go further into the future, obviously social media is is is the media, right?
So how I'm just curious, how do you navigate typically, you know, I know every case is wildly different. Uh, how do you navigate something that is so like decentralized, I guess, right? To to put it like that, right? Where everyone So it's very important to define your situation, your scenario, your role, the role that you'd like to play, um, and then really go hard on it. Uh, you can see young celebrities, young reporters or reporter type storytellers really lean in to their, excuse me, personal brand. And when you lean into your personal brand, that means that people will recognize you immediately.
Um, you know, there's everybody from new types of red carpet reporters to the person who covers only in Dade down here in Florida, uh, to, uh, the person who was the immediate reporter in in Hawaii who covered some much of the amount of county fires. Um and that sort of distributed ecosystem means that those people are building a very trusted, very thorough audience. Um that in turn hopefully uh is in keeping with the values that they set out at the beginning. I think that many of us are driven to uh perhaps embellish the truth or otherwise use social tools uh to build audience irrespective of those values, but uh I feel strongly that if you shape them uh carefully, uh you will be put in a position where you do stand out, you are unique, and ultimately hopefully you are telling your truth to your audience, uh whatever that might mean to you. And so it it really just kind of depends. Um what I do tell people to do though as a first step is to just pick one platform and be very good at that platform.
Uh there are many, many, many different ways to communicate with your audience from, you know, a WhatsApp broadcast channel all the way through a variety of uh country specific apps where, you know, you might be using LINE, but LINE is incredibly popular in Korea. You could be using uh WhatsApp Business and working in the Middle East across country lines that are very difficult to cross. You could be on TikTok, which in theory, at least this week, is one of the most popular ways of communicating with a large audience. Um and you may actually make a little bit of money off of it. But uh mostly it's showing showing off your values and and really leaning into um building the type of audience that's most meaningful and important to you is is key to making a brand that stands out and ultimately uh gives you the resources and and access that you're looking for. Depending on what you do, um you know, we it's interesting to see the democratization of media because it was such a limiting factor before and now the audiences are everywhere uh for all sorts of different reasons.
Um and it's not just about being beautiful, it's not just about being smart, it's not being incisive, it's Um it's it's about everything. Um and it's your look, it's your it's your tone, it's your aesthetic, um it's your affect, and it's also the kinds of stories that you're putting out there. Um and I think every platform has a different point of access and every platform has a different uh ROI and it just kind of depends what you're going for as you build out whoever it is that you want to be in the public space. Um the caveat being really using your whole personality uh to be if you ever want to capitalize or sell um that IP. Uh if it is your whole personality, it's going to be very, very difficult to to to uh divide yourself uh from that. And that's that's something to really consider uh as you continue and grow um in this space.
I'm sure any business owners that are listening, I'm sure there's a lot of gems even within the personal branding element of everything that you're talking. Um now I'm curious to pivot back to uh leadership and and team development. What has that journey looked like for you? Um I know you you yourself come from with deep domain expertise um within journalism and you're able to transfer that to this business. What did it look like to build a a team of of other people um in this very highly uh specialized business that you I've been very lucky that everyone who works for me has been here for a long time um and we've effectively built the business together. Uh I think that may change in the coming months if we choose to expand, but uh as it sits right this second um my team have just sort of grown with me um and in particular they've they've really outdone themselves in in becoming um the best person suited to the role that they've chosen.
Um and so that's great. I think the pain point that everybody talks about, which is like growth past your first or second team, uh comes to mind because it's it's since our company is so personality based and personality driven, it's actually difficult to figure out how to expand it. Um you know, everything that we do is personal relationships. The reason our prices can be high is because personal relationships. Um and the reason that we have so many clients that come back to us time and time again, no matter what's going on, um is again personal relationships. And that's just different um than anything that's scalable.
You know, we're never going to be SaaS, we're never going to be uh out here selling widgets. Our only uh sellable product is our time. It's It's an interesting challenge to figure out what to do with that uh especially since I I actually don't like to put myself on on platforms uh as a personality these days and So, what So, I see that I guess you from what I'm hearing, you're still in the space of I guess as you said you mentioned deciding whether you're going to scale or not and most of your team have been with you and they've done a phenomenal job at at at at at the business. So, I'm curious what what have been like lessons that you've gathered along the journey that you feel Um, you know, there are a lot of untoward lessons that I've learned over the years. Yeah, we've had all sorts of different adventures, but the first thing is is really understanding um who your ideal clients are and who your ideal customers are depending on how you look at people that you work with. Um, but those things are are really really If you're building services for individuals, you have to really cater to their needs and their their styles of working and that can be the little things like Microsoft Teams versus Google um or it could be the big things which is, you know, showing up to their house for dinner or really participating in long conversations with them or, you know, answering the phone at 3:00 in the morning when they're worried and that's something to be really cognizant of, I think.
Um, and so that's something to to really think about too as you continue in your in your journey as an entrepreneur. It's like how does my product work for this market and does it need to change or grow with the times um because sometimes it doesn't. Sometimes it it is really the personality that they're looking for um and other times it's just how many views can we get on TikTok or how many widgets can I sell. And And And maybe aside from the dynamics of identifying like your ICP and being very clear who your who your client is, what they want, kind of navigating that that process, what what what did the journey look like for you as far as um you developing as a leader for your team uh especially from when you started 10 years ago to now like Oh, I mean, you know, where I like to have very independent people working for me and so what we have created is the opportunity for independent people to lead their own environments. Um, it's essentially uh almost cooperative in the way that we work um and people know uh what they're what they want to do or how they want to do it um and I think that that's a bit different. You know, we're not doing structured team retreats.
We're not out here uh all reading doing a book club, perhaps we should, um but at this point it's here every team leader effectively takes points on their on their case and runs it through to the ground um and sometimes that's a month and sometimes it's years and sometimes it's weeks and you never know. Um, but our tactics are really like work openly, work honestly um and then have solid work-life balance if it's possible for you and if that's what you want. Uh, we also of course appreciate and cater to workaholics whenever we have them, but um most of the time my goal is to just make it so that you are working in a place that you want to work uh as long as you want to work there um because we have such niche uh topics at hand sometimes, you know, we we do a lot of research, we understand the issue um together and and we do a lot of crib notes and and sheets to to work forward. But I got to say I'm probably the most relaxed version of one of the of a leader um I think mostly because my team have been so good over the years and they haven't required that much direction. It's uh definitely a case where making the investment has really helped um to hire the right person for the role and so we've been super lucky. I've seen my peers really struggle with being willing to delegate um and uh not cater to the expertise of the staff, um but my perspective is I hired you for a reason, you seem to have expertise on the matter, I'm going to trust you to know what you're doing.
Um, it's only bit me in the ass a couple times so um I I still hang out there. But, you know, it just it just kind of depends. I mean, I feel like a lot of folks really want to come in and and really boss people around and I I sure why you would want to do that and I appreciate wanting to micromanage um to some extent but yeah I don't I don't know that that is as applicable here unfortunately um as it might be for another company um in part because we what we do is so so weird um and so nuanced that it it can't it can't be scaled necessarily um I see a lot of the big agencies have crisis teams and it's still going to come down to the person that runs the crisis team every single time and it's going to come down to the reactions that they have in the moment and uh yeah we may have all the same playbook which is sort of respond engage deflect and and uh attempt to move forward um but you're also going to have to make those game day decisions where that response comes off as tone deaf and it's not going to work uh for the company so it it just kind of really depends um that's why you hire comms people that's why you hire specifically crisis comms people um you know we have a different attitude and aptitude for things um but it also means that it's difficult to kind of come out here and say here's the formula it's going to fix everything uh because there isn't one who has a book company uh he helps entrepreneurs create books uh like really fast and the whole idea is to put the framework in a book uh as a like a lead magnet to like help promote the business and generate clients so I'm and so just I guess for clarity in your case I know you mentioned like these specific words like um I think you said engage uh deflect and you I think you mentioned about two others um is there a framework that you follow um just broadly speaking um out of curiosity or or not really there is a pattern um and we essentially someone calls we assess the situation uh we determine first if it's um fixable or addressable uh sometimes people will call and I'll just be like yeah sorry that's going to happen um but if they if they go through that then we go through a thought tree of the different possibilities of how this might play out sometimes we do that in a formal exercise with the client and their attorneys other times we do that rapid paste on that first call it it just kind of depends I and I don't have a better uh system um sometimes the client is overly emotional at the time that they've engaged us and so we're figuring that out uh we're figuring out the best way for that person or or brand or group of companies or whatever it is uh to uh tone down some of that emotionality uh oftentimes we take away their phone or other engagement device of some sort um so that we can mitigate their access to the internet for a near uh period of time um and then we look at the business ramifications first uh we do sort of a physical assessment and provided that they're not in physical danger it's it's very much uh how is this going to have an effect on the way that you make money or generate revenue or ultimately the overarching value of your brand and what direction are we going from there and that's the the type of question uh that we can't always answer initially sometimes people have a very obvious way of of making money and other times it's it's very nuanced or subtle or it's it's sometimes also family money or something like that or sometimes they're flat broke and it looks like they've been living the life of Riley and in fact they're you know sleeping on somebody's couch someplace and we try to take that into account like what is your goal here and how do we get there um I have been very fortunate that uh the people who walk in the door typically have some understanding of the impact I guess uh that's going to happen um and they often are coming to us on the worst day of their lives so we are often you know over very present and emotionally available to them uh while we figure out what's going to happen um if we see that it's going to tank their business for example we'll discuss how they're going to their immediate future in that context um if they are going to go to jail uh we discuss whether or not what the attorneys are going to do and what the direction should be uh from there um and then we also have a pretty frank conversation with the lawyers about whether or not we think that the individual is going to have a chance of getting out of it whatever it is and I can't you know because in 87 different events I can tell you 87 different things happens in some way some people rebound and are stronger than ever and typically people who've been canceled come back within two to five years if they're going to come back as public figures other people use public opinion ways in their favor and they get access to things that they never expected and still others get a book deal and make a TV show and then continue on their merry way but it it really just kind of depends but it is all about that response in the first 72 hours of of any particular quandary. What do you what do you see you taking Grey House in the future like what what do you yeah what do you we will be part probably part a small part a specialized part of a bigger agency if only because that would smooth out some of the dramatic cash flow drama that we have as as something that that works really hard in spurts but you know we've been an independent agency the whole time I've been working it means that we are a very unique workplace it means that people who work here feel super lucky that they work here because they can do just about anything that they want as long as they finish their homework on time and it's awfully remote and all of that but I don't know I I it's it's one of the reasons that my name's not on the door is because I just really wanted it to be able to stand separately from me actually a lot of my peers in in media and particularly in communications need that name recognition and it's not necessarily something that excuse me is is vital to my future as an entrepreneur I I have to say I always thought I was going to be the CEO of the New York Times and life has pivoted a bit and this is kind of more fun especially in this era of media but it's it's also a huge adventure and I can't come out here and say this is my goal because I'm not sure what that's going to be. Obviously this is fascinating to me honestly I mean the laugh maybe one day in the future I'm I'm super famous and hopefully I won't need any of these services you know who knows but I think that it's good because there are a lot of entrepreneurs within our community and hey people have real lives and real things happen to them right and so you know maybe somebody yeah. You know the most dramatic ones are almost always the ones extraordinarily immediately relevant and that is your PTA it's your small town politics it's your gym coach who you know gets in a car accident and does something dumb it's your principal who goes wandering and you're just kind of like why did you do that or things like that where it has such a dramatic effect on a small small population of people who care very very very much the big ones kind of like float over your head so if you look at like free Britney a couple years ago as interesting as that may have been to watch the direct impact on you of whether or not Britney Spears has her own Instagram password is is not particularly significant you know we can make you watch it because God knows you're watching it and you'll watch her Instagram for the rest of your life because it's so unusual but her fan club getting her out of what they perceived as custodial guardianship is a very different problem that is unlikely to affect the function of of individual humans on a day-to-day basis and that's just something that that we think about we also when we talk about me too like if you look at any of the women that we've ever represented and you definitely have clicked on some links what you're going to see is they were fortunate some of them are very fortunate that their opponent was a man in power and thus that person had resources and so their just deserts included getting a lot of their opponent's cash and it felt like a payout most people if they're sexually assaulted don't necessarily have that ROI.
And so whilst you may have the pain and the suffering and everything like that, you don't necessarily get the justice. And I think that that is one of the challenges of this sort of of communications is just because it was resolved in a high profile way doesn't mean that it has a meaningful impact on your personal existence. Um in some cases it does change the law, but even then if if uh your circumstance that may be parallel to theirs um were to be reported, it might not give you what you're hoping for. Um and so there's there are a lot of different things that come from crisis communications. Um we often spend years with our clients kind of behind the scenes just coaching them down uh to some sort of sustainable path and relationship with the internet in particular. Um but you know, a lot of this stuff has long-term change uh implications of long-term change for for the individual or the company.
Um and we've seen a lot of strange things happen afterwards. I mean maybe just to follow up on that, what what are do you have aspirations or is the I'm going to use this I guess this probably connects to the 20% of my proper piece, but like I'm curious like what specific causes or even policies that you may be um through your company helping to push for um so that Yeah. Yeah, so this year uh and last year too, uh we were very happy to represent Plan C, which is an medication abortion medication abortion access group, and they are sort of guerrilla warfare on the on the front uh of the American uh abortion rights drama. Um and they've done extraordinary work in public spaces. Uh we've also were were strangely lucky and surprised uh to find that we were representing Melissa Mills, who's the third daughter of the woman who is known as Jane Roe. Um and we represented her for several months uh whilst we were all discussing the end of Roe versus Wade and the on the consequences there.
Uh and then we've also represented a ton of women uh at the forefront of the Me Too movement, at the forefront of the fight against online harassment. Um and we've also worked with the queer community on making sure that folks have access to the types of care that they need, um which is a different type of a progressive cause. Um and then during uh the George the events after George Floyd's death, uh we were able to give a lot of time to uh diverse uh groups of founders and individuals who wanted to be more prominent um as in the context of whatever work they were doing. Um so all of those things just kind of depend are are good causes. We've spent um before George Floyd, we were working primarily actually on the environment. And we will probably also do an environmental project or two this year.
Um I'd imagine we will address climate change in some fashion, uh but I'm not sure how we're going to do that yet. anyone that across some type of personal branding crises, you're going to be the first person that comes to mind. And that's great um because I feel like I just gained a resource here. And anybody who's listening to this honestly because I don't think these type of services are top of mind to people at all. There's uh it it yeah, it is actually people in the US who do this and of those two or 300, I like to think that we're some of the we that we're very very passionate about it when it when it appears. Uh we do many of the things in support of our work, but but crisis is absolutely my favorite thing.
Well, um okay, thank you so much. Uh anything else you would want to add um before No worry. Now um you know, I would just say that uh if folks are reaching out to me or someone like me, just be really realistic uh that whilst a precipitating event may happen very quickly, the resolution doesn't usually come very fast. And it is important to understand that a few minutes online for example can really change your life. Um and also you know, they can't be taken back. The internet is more permanent in a different way than anything that came before it.
Yeah, it's just like both like a good thing and like a bad thing. You know what I'm saying? Like if the bad yeah. Because one screw up that you because we're all human, you know, and nobody's perfect. And sometimes people do things without intention or something like that, you know? And so it's crazy uh to think about it that we all got to be really careful about I guess how we operate.
Um but you know, it's good to know that um there's services out there like yours to help mitigate that. Especially like something that comes to mind is like let's say somebody's trying to like um spread something about someone else. Sorry, what did you say? No worries, no worries. I got a lag. Anyone who wants to reach out is welcome to do so.
I'm really easy to find online. Um and Joelle, I'm sure you're going to send me a link sometime soon and it will be on all of my social platforms uh whenever it comes to life. But if you have any questions, feel free to to to send an email. I'm always available. Thank you so much, Kay. It was a pleasure.
I learned a lot. I know anybody who's tuning in has learned a lot. And just want to say thank you so much again. Yeah, nice to see you.