Kate Gardiner #038
- Show
- EventSpeak with Big John
- Host
- Big John
- Air date
- (eventspeak.com / YouTube); iHeart listing dated February 1, 2021
This is an unedited transcript and may contain errors.
I think that there's a cultural dynamic where uh those of us who have had the fortune of walking straight through the the prescription you know you go to college you may get a masters you uh have a whole bunch of internships and that proves your your worth and you climb the ladder very carefully um that relies on understanding how that process works and I think that there's there's a deep gulf between education and the people whose cultures we tend to appropriate and so that is something where you have to do probably twice as much four times as much work to get that person to understand how the system works and either help them to change the system so that it can work for them or help them to fit into the system in a way that's meaningful and leads to them to be able to be successful uh and I think that it may not seem like that work is is worth it and it may also seem like that work is overwhelming or that it might yield less of a bottom line but I think that investing in your talent and and really showing that you mean what you say is something that all of us who are in leadership positions and all of us who have have led these change these changed movements in in our at our agencies and around the world I think we we're in a position where we have to actually mean it and we have to stick to what we said um and it is it's so it rings so hollow when people are just like well we have four open seats and and two of them should be filled by people of color that it it doesn't it doesn't work quite that way. Welcome to Event Speak with me Big John CEO of Beyond Experiential. So today's guest is Kate Gardiner she is the founder and CEO of Grey Horse. They are a full-service communication agency based in New York and we're thrilled to have her on the show today. Kate thanks so much for joining us welcome to Event Speak. Hey nice to be here thanks for having me.
Absolutely absolutely so Kate tell us a bit about who you are and what you do and what Grey Horse is all about. Sure so Grey Horse is a social justice first uh agency we do all of the usual stuff from you know your Instagram and Facebook posts all the way through global social strategies uh and all sorts of other PR communications things uh we've been instrumental in the me too movement with the environmental movement and all sorts of other uh types of organizations and and sort of cultural moments uh in addition to that we represent lots and lots of people from celebrities to uh prominent uh technologists and uh people that you know on on all sorts of platforms and we also work a lot with authors and books so we've launched lots of things that you've probably read um we've been here since about 2012 and my background is as a journalist so I went to Northwestern and Brandeis to study that uh way back when but thanks for having me. You know absolutely absolutely um now with your work it you've it's very impressive you guys have been recognized by uh many different organizations uh Forbes 30 under 30 Emmy nominations uh the next J fellowship by Radio Television Digital News Association um I mean just to name a few is is there one of these that's really special to you and Grey Horse and if so why? Uh the awards are what they are I mean we all are cynical about them at this point but it was uh it was a turning point to get the Forbes 30 under 30 if only because at 29 and a half it's the last time I could get that um but it was also important to me uh because it puts you on a different scale and the the opportunities that it afforded us sort of open many many doors uh it put me on all sorts of committees and I traveled all over the world as both a speaker and and that type type of person as well as as someone who's gotten the opportunity to consult on all sorts of different things that have happened uh in the last 10 years um so I think you know since 2015 it it that one really changed the way that we uh work and were able to work. That's um that's got to be you know something where like as you said if if nothing else uh with awards they they kind of give you that much more of a voice sometimes and open up those doors for you to be able to uh to be able to pursue out even further into what you're doing. So, I mean it sounds like Grey Horse is multifaceted.
You got you you mentioned several uh different uh avenues that you guys you guys go down. Would you say um would you say in what capacity do events play into uh your portfolio? As we were talking off camera, you mentioned it's about a 30-year business, right? So, we believe in audience engagement and community strategy and as part of that, there's actually a real life component. And so, we have thrown huge events. Our biggest is two or three thousand people.
Our smallest are typically 10 to 20 people. Um these days we do Zooms that go anywhere from 10 people to 200. Uh we're actually executing a a conference we expect to be in the thousands at the beginning of December at the moment. Um and it it it's it's interesting because our events are a part of our communication strategy for our clients. Um they're not always standalone. We of course do standalone events when they come in um but in general, they're part of a brand building or community building effort for whoever it is we're speaking with.
And that changes on a quarterly basis because hey, it's pandemic. But uh that's that's the philosophy that came into building the agency. In general, we see ourselves as a vertically integrated communications firm. So, we can do everything from your Twitter to bringing 700 of your clients to somewhere remote for a retreat. Wow, okay. So, I've got to ask you, you know, coming from a journalist background, um you you've created clearly a a multifaceted agency.
Like walk me through the journey if you will, the Wikipedia version of it. Like how how did you how were you able to build this? Uh essentially, I mean I'm guessing it was you to start. You had this idea. It's still mostly me these days. Um so, so it you you shape you give it more shape than it probably had.
Uh basically, I was a really good freelancer. Uh and so, I kept needing to hire people because I would win more work than I could possibly do. Uh and then someone told me that that's called an agency. And I was like, oh, okay, cool. Uh and so, that's kind of how it came together. Uh I had business partners for a while.
They left a few years ago. Um and in general, I have really enjoyed uh building my own company. Uh both my parents are entrepreneurs. My dad's an attorney and my mom's a shepherd. And so, uh between them, I've watched them build businesses my whole life. And it occurred to me that I didn't really ever learn how to be sort of the corporate drone that that the modern media ecosystem really demands.
And so, I was a really strange person to hire sometimes. And I had a lot of very strange experiences because coming out of journalism school in 2009, we had a mixture of the recession and the first recession and also just utter chaos in the media industry as the the media model fell apart. Um so, I I also started out in consulting which was how to rebuild your media organization and shape it for the future. Uh and I wanted to get beyond firing people. So, that's what I I I I get it. I get it.
Believe me. Um you know, while very different, my my my path hasn't been too different than yours. You know, I think that there's it's interesting when you as you said, you're a freelancer and you know, I think we've all freelanced and probably still freelance even as we create agencies. I feel like we just escalate our freelancing if anything, you know. Um and it's it's always interesting to see where sometimes just through through the need that you identify with your clients of what services you're able to offer and sometimes I think um I don't know about you, but we've found we have found that well hey, there's clearly a need for for this and we haven't considered that. Maybe this is something that we can accommodate.
Now, with you guys uh you know, you're clearly an advocate and a pioneer uh in the social justice capacity uh of bringing that into what you're doing with your agency. Uh can you offer some general advice for companies that are out there that are still you know, it's a male dominated business, male dominated world for that matter. Um both small and large, do you want to uh you know, they want to initiate, promote, and maybe change. Could you offer some general advice to those companies that might be out there watching right now of how they can do that? How to change in the context of of elevating women or how to change in the context of DEI or uh other things like that? Well, let's look at it from more of the equality standpoint where as you said, you know, to be able to give women a more uh of a voice and to be able to have a fair shot at, you know, opportunities and jobs they're qualified for but maybe aren't getting because it's a male dominated business.
Well, I think it's changed in the last little bit, uh if only because I'm hearing more and more complaints from straight white men that they can't get hired. So, at the moment, you're having a little bit of a renaissance. I don't know how long it'll last, um but I hope some of us are here to stay. Uh a good friend of mine, Katie Longmire, just got hired as the managing director of Mother, for example, um which is a really cool gig for her and and speaks to both her resume and also to the fact that she is an awesome, awesome lady of color, uh now in a leadership position. Um but she's, you know, few and far between. Um we also have a good friend who uh was just hired as the head of uh Amazon Prime Video, and she's going to get to be able to do all sorts of crazy stuff over there.
That's Ikram Ojo. Um I think that there are all sorts of different ways that you can elevate the women around you. Um I think I've heard all sorts of crazy things happening both in the apocalypse and the pandemic because our business has caught on fire. Um but also outside of that, where there seems to be a binary where you're either diving into the deep end of the pool and saying everyone should be black and queer and and all of these things, um and women and all of that, but uh it's lip service. It tends to be uh I don't know if it's meant necessarily or if it's understood. Um and I think that there's there's a part of it that has to be real because people really sniff out um anybody who's just just paying that that little bit of lip service to this social change movement.
Um but the other side of it is is elevating women who work with you or around you um and giving them the opportunity to lead the projects that they they bring into you or that they're working on. Um I think that there's a cultural dynamic where uh those of us who have had the fortune of walking straight through the the prescription, you know, you go to college, you may get a masters, you uh have a whole bunch of internships, and that proves your your worth, and you climb the ladder very carefully. Um that relies on understanding how that process works, and I think that there's there's a deep gulf between education and the people whose cultures we tend to appropriate. And so that is something where you have to do probably twice as much, four times as much work to get that person to understand how the system works and either help them to change the system so that it can work for them or help them to fit into the system in a way that's meaningful and leads to them to be able to be successful. Uh and I think that it may not seem like that work is is worth it, and it may also seem like that work is overwhelming or that it might yield less of a bottom line. But I think that investing in your talent and and really showing that you mean what you say is something that all of us who are in leadership positions and all of us who have have led these these change movements in in our at our agencies and around the world, I think we we're in a position where we have to actually mean it, and we have to stick to what we said.
Um and it is it's so it rings so hollow when people are just like, well, we have four open seats and and two of them be should be filled by people of color. That it it doesn't it doesn't work quite that way. Um Sure. because it's not quantifiable. It's walking the talk, if you will. You know?
Um and I feel like, you know, it's something, you know, we were talking a little bit off camera and how this pandemic is just, you know, you hear it so much, uh the terms like unprecedented are thrown around, and I I feel like that there have been some silver linings to it in the sense that there's everyone's having to rethink and reimagine what they're doing, especially uh in our collective industry. Um you know, obviously from the brand side of it, the event side of it, as a communications agency. Now, having your your fingers into clearly, you know, a few different a few different uh facets of uh your your client portfolio, beside obviously the event part of it that, you know, kind of enlivenment's gotten nixed, but where have you seen the biggest change from the pandemic and just in general in working with your clients, uh even let say from just having this this force of, you know, pushing digital and reimagining your digital strategy and your social strategy? Like where do you see the biggest difference now that we're into the pandemic from the perspective of what your client's needs are? I think that the scopes are wildly different. The scopes and the expectations are wildly different.
The KPIs and the deliverables are wildly different. Um and also the understanding of what all of that means. Um when I started doing this, people didn't know what I was talking about or or they denigrated it or they thought that, you know, 12 Twitter retweets is great. Um and they would be satisfied with these statistics because since the statistics were kind of meaningless, they couldn't really quantify them. And they didn't look at it didn't look like it was going to be sales. It didn't look like it was going to be brand impressions.
It didn't look like it was going to be useful in the context of business. In the context of personality, uh some of that engagement, some of that celebrity wasn't as valued then as it is now. Um and so having conversations about your Instagram and social media strategies and whichever other platform you choose um is something that's much more real and it tends to have more resources put behind it than it used to. Uh when I started doing this, fighting for, you know, $200 in Facebook advertising was this big battle and honestly, in in the grand scheme of things, it was pretty meaningless to some of those clients. Now, I have clients who come to me with tens and tens of thousands of dollars to spend on dynamic Facebook Facebook or social media advertising. Um and sometimes I have to caution them not to spend it all in one place, to diversify their strategies.
And that's a sophistication that took more than 10 years to grow. Uh and it's an understanding of the ROI on social media that's that's just completely changed the way that we work. In terms of communication strategy, uh a big part of our growth area this year has actually been crisis communications and helping to handle situations around cancel culture or helping to assist executives who found themselves in trouble for various reasons. Um and that has uh been something where sometimes there's no recourse. And I think that frustrates people with years of experiences experience and and heavy portfolios because they're like, well, I didn't do it or if I did do it, that is like, you know, 5 minutes in the scope of the 5,000 hours I've put into this. And they're just like, why is this so relevant?
Um and sometimes it's because you're physically hurting women, for example. We get people who come to me trying to get me to rescue them and I can't rescue you from that. Sometimes it's because you didn't mean what you said and then after D and I training and you thought that, you know, giving money to a cause would supplant the fact that you may have mistreated um the women of color who work for you or the LGBTQ people who work for you or the other folks who work for you who can't respect you anymore because of whatever it was that they perceived that you did. Um and I think that there's this this fight in these companies between the staff that may have not had a voice before or who were too afraid and the folks who are here now. Um and it's it's such a different way of being. I remember years ago, I was working on a production um and I'm being really vague, uh but an individual ended up throwing something at me.
He threw a stapler at me and I basically was done. I was I was going to walk off the floor. Um and I had the resources that I could get out of that situation and I could say, I don't want to work here anymore because you're frankly just impossible to work for and kind of a disgusting person. Most people don't have that those resources or that wherewithal. Um and I think that we underestimate how much people feel trapped in circumstances beyond their control and then that we also underestimate how much anger uh plays plays a role in the way that that folks are experiencing their workplaces. And and that is why folks are frustrated at creative agencies, in commercial settings, in all of these settings where ostensibly we're getting to do the work that we love, which is bringing people together, selling ideas, um putting ideas out in the world, storytelling.
Um and the reason that uh they don't want to stay anymore, that we lose talent ends up being because it's just it's it's impossible. It is not possible um to suffer indignity on a day-to-day basis and yet we continue to expect especially the younger people in the industry to do that. And they've been given this chance to fight back through cancel culture and they do. Uh I'm not on their side. I'm not on anyone's side, but I also hear the executives who say, hey, wait a second, I didn't mean it that way. It was misinterpreted.
It was misquoted. It was misscreen-shotted. Yeah, taken out of context or whatever the case might be. Um and that's that can be a huge huge issue. I also have talked to people who said, I didn't mean it that way and I want to make amends and there aren't any amends right now. We don't have a way to get past being canceled.
We don't have a way to get past uh internal social justice issues and we don't have a way to get past the fact that there are people who are trying to work in our industry who come from environments where decades and decades of hate have shaped the opinions and and thoughts that they have and Sure, I totally get it. So, two-part question. First one, if you are someone that may be watching now that might be experiencing what they feel is uh poor treatment or you know being discriminated against uh in their workplace or um um someone that you know is involved in a situation they feel that is not good for them, what recommendations would you give them for first initial steps to take? It's got to be an overwhelming thing like you know you said you're dealing with anger, you're probably there's probably this even a feeling of embarrassment that they however they're they're they might be treating you or calling you out. What would what advice would you give these folks or direction would you send them in? The most practical thing to do is document and document to your personal email address, document on your phone, document on a non-work device that you control.
Um put it into an archive folder, put it on Google Drive, put it somewhere. If you have photos, if you have text messages, if you have whatever other communications you can uh be aware of that. You're having issues with verbal harassment that is spoken as in it's a phone call or something like that. Um depending on what state you're in, you may be in a one-party consent state. If you are, you may be able to record that conversation and you can archive that um for later use uh if you get to a point where you'd like to pursue litigation. Um internally, if your organization has an HR department, bring it up to them.
HR can then elevate it to the proper channels. If you don't see evidence of that, then it's time to speak to any state governing body that deals with employment, um EEOC for example, OSHA in some circumstances, physical circumstances mostly. Um and then also any other state department that applies to the situation you see. Um the other thing that you can do is you can raise it to local or uh national employment attorneys uh if you'd like. Uh sometimes it's worth doing, sometimes it's not. Um but all of those things are very practical steps and are the more correct steps in the in the eyes of the law.
Um in the eyes of sort of the social justice like digital social justice movement um and in the context of the cancel culture, the first thing that you have to remember, and this is what I tell every single person who comes to me with these sorts of problems, um particularly in the context of sexual harassment, but overall in the context of poor treatment in some contact in some way, um you have to decide that you're okay with this being part of your life for many years. Um the average case that we work on is two to three years. We're often hired by litigation attorneys. Um and during the course of that two to three years, you may or may not be able to work based off of the situation you found yourself in. It will be held against you in many cases and there's absolutely no way to prove that. Um so you have to be aware that if you open this door, particularly on social platforms, in some ways it's fleeting uh and in other ways it is permanent and you have to have really made a reasoned decision about what you'd like to do in the circumstances.
If it's sexual harassment or physical assault or anything that's actually related to your personal safety, absolutely get out of that situation, absolutely be willing to talk about it in public, absolutely take it to the cops or take it to a governing body. Um if it is reputational issues or if it's just a he said she said thing, be careful about how you make those decisions and how you move forward before you get anywhere near um your social media feeds. Um and then if you do choose to pursue it on social platforms, work with a group of people, make sure that you're strategic, make sure you are aligned, and make sure that ultimately the consequences are something that you want to live with um because you could be ruining someone who didn't mean it's career and that's a conscious side of it. You could be taking down someone who is a serial abuser of of people who work in your area of the industry. Um and it's only up to you to tell, but it is also very something where you can also be held legally accountable if in fact uh it's proven that it's libel or slander. Um and so you have to be very very aware and also please for the love of God don't abuse this because trust from the public is very hard to earn and uh a lot of our sexual assault and sexual harassment regulations come under fire because of that one time that one girl lied about it um or that one time that one boy lied about it and that's just not worth uh the capital for the rest of us because what happens if you are the one who's sexually assaulted?
No, I totally I totally get it um and I think that's some some excellent guidelines and I'm sure that's be very helpful to a lot of people watching. I think there's probably a disturbing amount of folks that deal with this on a daily basis. and are just afraid because they they don't know and they're overwhelmed by it. Now, the second part of my question would be on the flip side of that, um obviously not to someone that is legitimately abusing people uh or monstrous in that kind of way, but to someone that perhaps something was taken out of context, perhaps uh uh maybe something was misconstrued, um obviously without letting the tricks out of the the the bag of of your arsenal, what what advice would you give them um you know to someone that may be finding themselves in a situation like that? Uh before anything else gets out into the public or before any you talk to anyone else, uh observe what your your agency, your entity's legal practices, best practices are. That means bring the issue to HR before HR brings the issue to you.
That means bring to your personal counsel if you have an attorney, bring to your executives, your boss, your manager, your leadership, whoever they are, bring it to them before the plaintiff, whoever they are, uh can carry it into the office. Be aware that there may be documentation that you are uh going to have to deal with. Documentation may be all of the stuff I just told somebody to put in her Google Drive. Uh documentation might be something like, hey, a camera in an elevator. Um documentation can be all sorts of different things that you aren't even aware of. It can be very cleverly cut screenshots from Slack, for example, if you think about what happened to Steph Curry over at Away.
Um it can be all sorts of other things. Um and the second thing to do is to be very aware and very careful uh about the ways that you engage with your staff, both below you and above you. Um and by careful I mean I have told time and time again, yes, we live in a party environment, no, you should not party with your employees. Um and you can take them out for a drink, one drink, but you're going to get in a hell of a lot of trouble if you accidentally do something or misconstru something misconstrue something someone says. In addition to that, you shouldn't be taking advantage of power. Uh it's a really, really hard time to have an inner office romance.
Please don't. Um it that will be so much more expensive than it was worth. And yes, okay, some of us have fallen in love with our colleagues, but in comparison, I don't know that that's always the case. Uh so be really cynical about what you're willing to do. If you wanted to be the most cautious of cautious, uh limit the number of one-on-one meetings you have, or if you do one-on-one meetings, do it in a way where the door's open or something like that. Uh if you absolutely must have a one-on-one meeting, particularly with a staffer who might be causing trouble in the context of DNI or who may be perceived as a troublemaker in the context of DNI, be aware of your documentation, take contemporaneous notes, notes either during the meeting or after the meeting, um email them to yourself, BCC yourself.
Um oftentimes one of the things we can't get is or at least can't get quickly is internal emails, uh so be conscious of that. Uh and also uh be aware that that any sentence you type into a into Slack or equivalent is something that can be discovered. Uh it is not hard for me to get an archive of Slack. It is not hard for me to get an archive of any other similar product that was made by someone else. Um and you just need to be aware that that sort of thing can be held against you. Uh in addition to that, um behaving with decorum is something that you just uh are obligated to do now.
Uh and I can't say that enough. I can't say that with with enough vigor even. Um you need to behave with good manners. You need to keep your cool during your meetings. You need to make sure that uh you know conventional swearing is fine, ad hominem attack type swearing is not. Uh that is and any time where a person who perhaps is not performing to their best uh is being disciplined for such things or being encouraged to behave differently, that is an opportunity where that person may or may not uh choose to engage with your ability to be their boss or their person of authority.
And in those cases, it is very hard to do the right thing, particularly if emotions are running high, but at the same time, if you don't behave, you can lose your career, and it's often not worth it for that production assistant who forgot to wake up on time. Um so it it really depends on on where you are in your career, but document, be circumspect, behave properly, keep your hands to yourself, don't drink with your colleagues, and above all, uh behave with respect towards other people's race, religion, creed, sexual orientation, and such. Excellent advice, Kate, that I'm sure, especially in this uh I mean we the tensions are running high across across the globe right now, especially in the pandemic and and everything that's going on, and uh as it is a time when we're we're we're finally seeing the needle start to move um in the fight for racial equality um and gender equality for that matter. Um I I can't tell you how much I sincerely appreciate you coming on the show and and sharing all of this with us. Um now something I'd like to do uh as we we get near the end of the interview is we'll shift gears a little bit lighter now and um I mean based based off of uh everything you've told us uh you're an amazing person, Kate, and by your accomplishments and what you're doing, uh I commend you. And I'd like to know, can you share something about Kate that people wouldn't know uh that you'd like to share with them?
Well, I don't know if people wouldn't know it, but I literally came to this interview straight off a horse. Uh so I've recently, during COVID, taken up horse uh the riding to the hounds, which is chasing various creatures all over the countryside in upstate New York. Uh actually today it was New Jersey. Um and it is my new favorite thing uh in a time where uh racing around the countryside on a horse is completely impractical on just about every possible level. Uh today we found three foxes and a cat. Uh the dogs got most excited about the cats, which is also kind of hilarious.
Um and uh yeah. Uh you know, I come from, as I said, my mother's a shepherd. Uh and so back home on the farm, uh there's a a part of my personality where I go stand out in the backyard hollering at the dogs to get the sheep to come in. And it is it is unique and it is I think I'm the only New York City, you know, West Village resident who uh does this to my knowledge, save for perhaps Sarah Montague over at WNYC. So So could I get perhaps an example of how you holler at the dogs? Say for example, you're on the back porch right now, do you think I could get that make that happen?
Can you give Uh no, no, no, thank you. Um but yeah, no, the the that it's a really interesting sport. So you you've got to wait to me and come by and I I swear to you I will do it backwards because my mother will then watch it and she will then inform me how I did the shepherding. Of how you did it wrong. Uh you know, that's uh it's it's interesting. I actually I'm I'm based in Burbank uh in Los Angeles area and I where I live um um is near the Equestrian Center.
Oh, great. Thank you. So it's really yeah, what's really great is uh one of my dearest friends, uh she and her uh 16-year-old son, they go riding all the time and come visit afterwards uh and they've taken me to the stables to to meet all the different horses and animals that live there uh as they utilize that for a lot of the the productions and films, you know, where the all these animals live. Uh but what's really great is around Burbank uh you'll, you know, you'll be heading over to the the corner convenience store in the middle of a busy mini mall on the corner like you see in LA and traffic going by and then there's a person riding a horse in a lane that's got a painted lane down the street with a sign that looks like it's for cars but it says horses only. And then you guys going down the street there, I'm like when I first moved here I was like kind of scratching my head. I'm like wait a minute.
Oh, okay, great, there's stables around. So I mean I'm I'm here for that. When I was living in London many years ago, we could do that, you know, the Wimbledon stables. It's actually right looking over the women Wimbledon tennis. Uh so that was fun. Um but yeah, you walk through town on your horse and it's like the best thing ever.
Oh, wow. It's it's something to this day where like in and now when I'm I'm out running around in the neighborhood and I I'll come across folks and sometimes people are walking the horse, uh they're, you know, going crossing the street, whatever. Everybody everyone that's local, we kind of have this, you know, wave and a nod kind of thing. Um that's that's really great, Kate, and I I really uh I really can't tell you again how much I appreciate you coming on the show today. Uh for anybody interested that maybe want to procure your services or know more about you, how can they find you? Uh so our websites are Grey Horse, g r e y h o r s e .
c c and my personal website is kategardner.com, g a r d i n e r. Uh you can also find me on just about any social platform at kategardner. Um and I can lead you down the garden path with the rest of my staff. Oh, that's that's really good. Lead you down the garden path. Leading down the garden path, uh Kate Gardiner from the Grey Horse Agency.
Thank you so much, Kate. And for all of you for watching and supporting us, thank you so much. Of course, we can continue this conversation over on Event Speak. That's at eventspeak.com. I'm still Big John, and reminding all of you to take care of yourselves and each other. We'll see you next time.