From Awareness to Action: How Stories Create Change | Kate Gardiner

Show
Harvesting Wisdom Podcast with Mike McMahon
Host
Mike McMahon
Air date

This is an unedited transcript and may contain errors.

Welcome to the Harvesting Wisdom podcast. Together we explore the vast landscapes of life, delving into the rich soil of experiences, sowing the seeds of curiosity, and harvesting the profound wisdom that each episode unfolds. Welcome to another podcast of uh Harvesting Wisdom. I'm your host Mike McMahon. With me today is Kate Gardiner. And uh Kate is um the founder and CEO of Last Word, formerly Grey Horse, a communications agency. Um and you've done a lot of uh cool stuff. NewsHour's first social media producer, um worked with Al Jazeera, uh New York Public Radio, and Newsweek. So you're it looks like you're uh really a journalist by nature or by training. So anyway, welcome to the uh show Kate. And uh um thanks for thanks for joining us. Um walk me through a little bit and the audience here about, you know, who you are, where you came from, why you're doing what you're doing, um you know, where did you get your training and all that. Uh let's start with that. Sure. So I'm Kate Gardiner. Uh I founded Last Word, formerly Grey Horse, uh in about 2010-2011 uh as a freelance way of doing a lot of work. And then it grew and grew and grew and in about 2015 became my full-time job. Uh we do communication strategies, public relations, and all sorts of other things related to talking to people. And our goal is to get audiences to be your advocate. Our goal is to hopefully turn things around if you're having a public moment you didn't consent to. Uh and our goal is generally uh to either make you money or make you famous depending on what you want. Um I grew up on uh between the south suburbs of Chicago and uh what is now a sort of sheep farm art gallery thing that my mom runs in southeastern Wisconsin. Um and we raise about 250 sheep a year, in part for harvest and in part because we are a stop on the national border collie training circuit. Uh so if you want to teach your border collie how to run in circles around sheep or cattle, uh we are one of the places you go to compete and to learn more about that. Um but most of the time I split between New York, uh Miami, and Chicago. And my husband and I live a sort of interesting traveling lifestyle between those three cities. I represent everything from people that you know from the headlines to people who've really tried to stay out of the headlines um and their businesses, their families, and sometimes even their lawyers. It really just kind of depends on the situation. Um So you're you're kind of the fixer. That's the goal. That's we try to fix it. If it can be fixed, we will do our best. Okay. So walk me through, you know, you know kind of what we do. We're involved with soil and we have our nonprofit, which is really an education platform um from preschool to senior level in high school. Um but it's it's garden based. In other words, it's agriculture based and it's designed for STEM. So yeah, a lot of our clients are environmentally inclined, I should say. Uh not all. Uh a lot are farmers, a lot are um school teachers, PhDs, soil scientists, water scientists. So we we cross some of the same paths as you do. But um walk me through a typical scenario. You don't have to mention names or real companies, but Sure. So it it depends a little bit. Um I'm going to try to stick to environmental examples because I think that that makes the most sense. Uh we work behind the scenes first on Years of Living Dangerously, which is the climate change documentary series that was produced in partnership with Showtime and now exists as the Years Project. Uh it is a climate change advocacy uh platform, an environmental platform that's supported by a lot of your favorite celebrities. Um and the goal of that series was awareness. It's an older series now, I think about 10 years, but uh it was super impactful because of how many people it brought uh like America Ferrera, Harrison Ford, Don Cheadle, it brought all those people uh into the climate change conversation, talking about the physical impact uh of the shifting temperatures on those things. I also worked on Chasing Coral. Chasing Coral was nominated for the documentary Oscar uh a few years ago. And Chasing Coral was a documentary about the precipitous decline of the Australian barrier reef and it's a very beautiful story. Uh it's a fun thing to look at in a way and also it's completely horrifying. Um it was very impactful because the pictures were so beautiful, but it was also something of a conundrum because it emphasized the fact that there's a relatively short shelf life for the Great Barrier Reef and also that it's at incredible risk um when water temperatures get so high. So those were two like big media pieces that we worked on. Um I'm also behind the scenes with a group called the Explorers Club. And the Explorers Club does that. It does what it says on the tin. And it's all about scientists and other folks who go out in the wilderness and collect data. And one of the things that we need to be able to effectively try to countermand climate change is data. Uh you have to know how many inches of rain you have or haven't had. Uh you have to know what's happening on the tallest peaks or in the in the bottom of the ocean. And these are the people who tend to go do that. Um and so in part of that, my husband runs a nonprofit about uh medical research in austere environments. And so Pulse at the Peak is specifically about gathering those bits of data and then fielding them to the right people. And we do that on a sort of annual basis because these expeditions are so hard to plan. Um but I've also worked with people like the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Ocean Agency, uh the Nature Conservancy, and a whole bunch of other of the bigger environmental nonprofits. And our goal has often been either awareness, which is telling community members and individuals who are directly affected uh by regulation or particular change um about something that's happening, or building grassroots movements to change legislation that particularly affects a a geographic region. Um near and dear to my heart is the island of Molokai between Oahu and Maui. Uh I've been there for almost 20 years. Uh and one of the things about being there is being incredibly aware of the impact that large-scale farming and agriculture have had on uh the west end of the island and also uh both in drought years and then this year in flood years, uh trying to figure out how to do water management for something that's often feast or famine. Uh for the last 15 years, every time we went to Molokai, I felt like it was going to catch on fire. Uh and then this year, I've seen uh the triple waterfall for the first time in my life because they've had so much rain from so many storms. Um so all of those things. Um I'm also on the board of a bunch of different conservation organizations and an avid fox hunter, which means I run around nature uh on the back of a horse trying very hard to catch a coyote and usually failing. So so that you've got a uh quite a few things going on from training border collies to uh climbing on a horse and chasing fox, um traveling the world with what you're doing. So let me um let me ask first the format because you're storytelling or you're um working with people with crisis management. They they may have done something they shouldn't have done or more likely in today's world, you just say something you shouldn't say, right? Um and um you know, if you've got a big pulpit pulpit, you know, when you say something a little off, it uh it can cause trouble. So when you're doing what you do, um I can see different forms of of how you're doing it. So you're doing some documentary work. So um that that goes in and that's environment. It's, you know, it could be anything, but you've done some environmental stuff. It looks like. My big thing really is trying to support regenerative farming in different aspects all over the world. I ask people, do you is climate change real? All over the world, the answer is yes. So uh I think we're we almost are getting tired of the concept of awareness um because everybody's already aware. You know, and if you look at Al Gore's campaign too, it's been 20 years of awareness. Well, what other awareness do you need? How about what is the change? So we're really more active. Our concept of change is the education platform. It's a STEM garden-based education uh platform. Um and we're not changing the mind of students. They're learning by by hands-on and by informational methods where they can now become better citizens and and what they decide to do with it is is up to them. But that's the the idea is that there's at least something um going on. Now um with with what you're doing, you've got clients coming. You said personal clients. And so walk me through um what a client could be. Could I be like uh an actor, then I said something really bad um or or is it more like That is the simplest version. Um Or Or how about I want to be associated with this movement. Can you help me do that? Is that something? Yes. So uh that's more often. Um so there's usually a precipitating event. The precipitating event could be a lawsuit. It could be I did something stupid in public. Uh it could be that I did something stupid in private and then someone figured it out and I'm not interested in being blackmailed so I take it public. Um sometimes it is something happened to me. Um those cases are often someone who did not expect to be a public figure finding themselves to be a public figure. Um but it really really just depends um on the nature of things. Uh right now I have previously worked on my one of my favorite crises of all time uh was the Good Food Foundation, Alice Waters Foundation uh out in the West Coast. She had a blue cheese crisis um where they got an incredible amount of press related directly to the fact that they declared a vegan blue cheese to be the cheese of the year. Um and so the the crisis element was uh this inundation of press to a very very small team uh and uh a couple of Colbert mentions and a whole bunch of other stuff. Um and trying to figure out how to manage that and also how to turn it into something that they could use for grassroots development uh because they suddenly had this this brand stand standard to stand upon uh but they didn't know what to say. And also uh you know while it's kind of funny, it's also was a a teaching moment where we had uh a societal shift to the taste of something that is inherently not a cheese was so cheese-like that it could win against people who had spent decades perfecting their blue cheese. Um and so for them it was it was a really really big deal. Um but broadly when I work with uh folks who are dealing with environmental issues, uh we used to say when I was working for NRDC, you had to have a polar bear. You had to have a cute little marmot. You had to have some sort of critter uh for these issues to resonate. And you may have seen that recently with With a tear in its eye. Exactly. Really sad turtle, you know. Um and we have kind of moved past that strategy a little bit but I have to say like recent campaigns about the wolves uh in Wyoming seemed to be very very successful for those organizations that were running them. Uh the ongoing dilemma of the wild horses um and all of their situation is is something that grabs headlines because everyone clicks on it. Um and it really kind of depends on your situation in terms of what we could talk about. Um in Hawaii we actually talk about soil a lot. Uh and the reason we talk about soil is because either it's blowing away or the pineapple companies left behind all sorts of fertilizers and whatnot in the dirt. And when you take that Hawaii, just Hawaii? Everywhere on the planet that's the case. It is. And in particular in Hawaii though you when they scoop uh the pineapple dirt off the pineapple fields and then they drive it over to America's longest barrier reef and they dump it on the reef, it turns out all those things that kill everything else also kills coral. Um and then that really inhibits the fisheries. And so we had a lot of issues with that. We also had a lot of issues with um pollutants coming from vehicles because obviously there's very little that is native to Hawaii that's in a vehicle. And uh there's also no way to dump your your abandoned car. So like if you wanted to junk your car, there's no way to do it. And so then those those vehicles end up rotting in these beautiful pristine forests. But it's partially because very poor people cannot um figure out what else to do with it. Yeah. So it's there's a lot of things like that. Um I've done a lot of work on just basic storytelling for complex issues. So unpredictable consequences. Like the car thing uh was this was an actual investigation that we did that was like why are there 150 cars on this very small island sitting on the side of the road? And the answer was that there was an environmental right that came down from Honolulu that worked for Honolulu because they have enough population but really didn't work uh from Molokai. And so when they change the rule and the standard in Hawaii is except for Molokai as in a lot of bills and a lot of legislation, um but they change that because of our storytelling. And so things like that are are the most simple ways of getting narratives out there. Um more complex narratives are uh something I deal with a lot, which is conservation easements. If I put my land into a trust, if I put my land uh into a conservation group and I take that tax benefit um on the one hand that's super beneficial. On the other hand, it does directly affect the value of my house. It directly affects the value of the land in question. Um and that may affect my legacy. And so if you're interested or concerned about your legacy, we try to figure out a a way to massage that so that you have the freedom or your heirs have the freedom to rebuild the house or otherwise mess with what they're inheriting while still also protecting wild lands if you have them or uh farmlands or whatever else. Um so it depends. We tell a lot of different types of stories depending on the circumstances. Uh when I'm advocating for a family or a group of people, um the way that we tell the story is is particular to them. Uh when we're advocating or dissuading a corporation, it's a little bit different. And then if we're also moving for legislative purposes, it's that's completely different as well. So it it depends on what we want to do. Go ahead. Okay, so let's I could go on about a thousand tangents with every statement you just made. Everything you're talking about is complex. It's complex because of people involved. So there's policy, who's governing, a common situation. There's uh a lot of different things. But I'm curious to see what, you know, for you to have the capacity to do what you're doing, how did you develop your skill set? So you're talking about stories. Everything is story-based, right? So um did you have a background in English and in writing and is that kind of the core? Yeah, so my uh undergrad is in American studies, which is American studies even, um which is the study of American essentially literature, but it includes film, uh radio, and other media. So it's it's it's content agnostic or or media agnostic. Um and then I did my masters at Medill, which is Northwestern University's journalism school. It's a famous old You're Canadian at one point? No, Medill uh in Chicago. Oh, not okay, not McGill. Okay. We did have there is a guy who graduated from McGill and Medill in my graduating class from Medill. Very confounding. Um Oh, wow. They call him the dill pickle. Uh exactly, exactly. Um so um but yeah, the storytelling shifted. So one of the things that was happening is I finished school and this is almost I finished undergrad in '07 and I finished grad school in '09. Um one of the things that came from that was that uh we were just about to have the digital apocalypse for the media. And when I talk about content agnosticism, there are people who are religiously opposed to that. Um they are writers, they are editors, they are TV people, they are radio people, they are movie people. Um and I don't care. I am like this media will work for this group of people because this is how they consume content. Um and I actually ended up that's what I did my master's thesis about uh at Kellogg was, okay, we have a group of people who use their iPhone every 10 seconds and we have a group of people who still get information off of billboards. How do we make sure that we are sharing the same information with those people um across these different environments? Um and we did a campaign for UNICEF Africa um about the ending child marriage maybe I think in 2022. And one of the biggest things that we did was we booked the bus TVs. Um and booking bus TVs only costs you like $500 for distribution uh in whichever country you're working in. Um but it also has the most direct impact because all these people are spending 8 to 10 hours on the bus going back to their families for various holidays. And so if you buy the holiday bus, you are essentially force-feeding your documentary um to all these people who are trapped on a bus uh for a really long time. And eventually some of it sticks if it's in the language that they speak. So uh we've done campaigns like that. We've built mobile apps. Um when I was at Al Jazeera, we built the thing that made it so that you could toggle like do a Facebook poll and it would show up on the screen. Um that spoke to the younger generation um and it also spoke to the old folks because old folks are watching it on TV and the younger folks are playing with the Facebook button um and then watching it on TV, which is also entertaining. Um so it really scales to the situation. Um we all consume media in the way that is imprinted on us when we're under 18. And so depending on what device you have at the time and um you may be a radio person, you might be a TV person, especially these days you could be an internet person. Um, We all listen to the same three country western songs we listened to 40 years ago. Exactly. You listen to that one, right? Yeah. So let me ask on this though. This is uh uh interesting. So you've come to the realization that it's you you just call it media. Whether or not you're writing a story about the magazine or a commercial or whatever, um it it starts with that. Um, the format of how you communicate it, whether it's radio, television or social media or if it's a film. Uh, so you have to navigate through all of that. I don't know how much of that you had to learn along the way or how much you subcontracted or worked with other people who were experts in those space or did you just become the expert? I see in 2016 you were with the 3030 Club at Forbes. That's at least 10 years ago. So now you'd be in the 4040 Club. But that at that age at 40 um you're you're like you're not as old as me, but you're kind of a dinosaur when we look at the digital apocalypse, right? Because there's which which digital apocalypse are we even talking about? Now it's AI has changed everything in the last two years drastically. Well now the most annoying thing that uh one of my so one of my mentees is uh a graduate of many of our highest universities and she's currently doing a PhD at Stanford and uh her counterpart who's currently at the MIT Media Lab told me that nobody reads books and so he's never going to write a book and I said okay, you don't have to write a book. Uh, a lot of people like it when you write a book though just so you know and he's like like militantly against doing this because he's 27 or 30 or something. It's hard to tell. And I was like Well, I've I've been in the middle of six different books on top of the books we did for our education platform that I started in 2019. But I'm actually came to the realization I'm kind of a horrible writer. You have to do the whole story thing and it's like come on, I just want to describe whatever I'm dealing with. But and then a month or so ago the Atlantic came out saying, you know, books are dead. It's it is an interesting format how people get information now. I don't I'd like love to hear your personal take on it. I think that um it'll have to come around. I think we got to reels now and we've got to hook points um and and nothing is more than 10 or 20 seconds long. Uh, we're all uh part of the algorithms that you know addict us to uh to all these different forms of social media. But so what is your do you see it coming around at some point? How do you find authenticity? How do you see this going? So that part's the most frustrating to me um and I think what's really interesting is while we are creating all these new celebrities on TikTok um and I have had friends built uh robots like Michaela uh where they are an entirely AI generated person uh who has uh sort of a soap opera of an existence. I think that those are cute and fun. I don't know that we've hit yet and we are on our path to it, but I don't think that we've got the data the robot from Star Trek just yet. Um, and that's and it's okay with me either way. Uh, I think it is impossible to be comprehensive in if you're just one person on all platforms in a to engage on each of those platforms in the way that feels meaningful to the community that mostly spends its time on those platforms. Um, and that's fine. I don't think anyone was ever meant to be comprehensive. I think that mostly what we're trying to do is to get speak to an audience that would care about the thing that we want to talk about. I think books are a fantastic way of starting a conversation and that's even if you haven't read the book um because you've probably interacted with some part of the story that the author was trying to put out there. I think that one of the things that has been interesting about the last few last decade of books is is really actually that we just print too many of them. We we have we are allowing to we democratize the creation of books to a point where having a book doesn't necessarily mean that the book is going to be any good. Um, and so then we run into this bigger problem which is yes, okay, fine, everyone and their sister can have a book deal. I've been approached several times. We have we have people who have no business and writing a book who write books anyway because that's what they're told to do is the next stage of their career and I step back from that and I tell people the reason we are doing this are for these discrete purposes. The process of creating a book may not naturally come to you, but I also encourage you strongly to consider something else, how we're going to use the book to move forward. The vast majority of books that I've worked on are not necessarily multi-generational. It may be a reflection of the moment, but they're not they're definitely not Shakespeare, right? They're definitely not any chapter of the Bible. They are sometimes technical, sometimes they're telling a story that could have been told in 10 pages, but the author got a 180 page book deal, so it's 181. But it isn't necessarily to me that the book needs to exist because of the content of the book. I think that the book exists as a recognition of this particular moment in time. It is a reflection of that particular person's experience as it relates to an academic or intellectual subject, and it is something that hopefully if it doesn't necessarily move the conversation forward, it does inform people about a particular ideological perspective or technical perspective or something. I think fiction's in a completely different bucket, so I'm not talking about that, but I am talking about this in the context of educational-ish or non-fiction. And So are you working are you working with nonprofits or with I work with a lot of different people. I have about 300 more across the board with pretty much everyone out there. A piece of content. If you would like your piece of content to get out into the world, we talk about how the piece of content or the personality should get to the world and why it should do so. And sometimes that's from a crisis perspective and sometimes that's from a popular perspective and sometimes that's just because you're really good at TikTok. Yeah, because you're you're kind of in between all these spaces, but I think that's the the essence of how you're servicing a client. There's probably not if if somebody's in trouble for some reason, or not just in trouble, if they want to move something forward, there's not a lot of people who are enough of I'm going to call you a generalist because you're operating almost every media type and you you're taking story-driven stuff, but you're also understanding the audience, who they're talking to, because otherwise you're spraying and praying, right? Well, so I actually so people who naturally gravitate to radio or podcasts or who are big talkers, I actually usually encourage you to basically have a conversation that you happen to record and transcribe and then turn into your content because sometimes that is better if you're not naturally going to sit down at your keyboard and bang away. Sometimes it's important to go about it that way. But the bigger picture, the reason I always encourage people to think this way and to really to explore what media works for them is mostly because we all can be good at one of these platforms. You could be good at Twitter or whatever we're calling it. We could be good at podcasting or radio. You might brighten up on on TV or on whatever digital video experience you'd like, or you could be incredibly perfectly suited for a 20-minute 20-second skit on TikTok or Instagram Reels. And I'm impartial to that. I think everybody can find a platform that suits them, and I think that if you think about your distribution correctly, you will make the biggest impact you can given the thoughts that you're expressing on the platform that suits you. I just want to make sure that you're optimizing your experience in that space so that you're having the kind of impact that you'd like to have. Sometimes we're looking at trying to make money from it, sometimes we're just looking for fame and fortune, and sometimes you're just looking for friendship and community. I think one of the things that's really interesting about our current existence is that we have made it so that people don't have to be in the same space as other people as much as they used to, and that has facilitated a whole generation of not necessarily isolationists, but people who are lonely or alone, and media is the way that you communicate with one or more other people. You know, it's it's really really interesting that. Yeah, I think there's people who live literally in a digital world and rest of the world. Um and who's to say what's right or wrong on on on this but uh in and I go always as I'm as I'm going to different parts of the world or I'm talking to people or I'm learning things it can be a depressing place this this planet and dealing with people but at the same time there's so many new exciting things um I see solutions out there just ready to be applied everywhere if uh um if I I think community has to come together and decide what's important to make that happen so having um someone on like you on board can save probably years worth of uh toil and doing things the wrong way I would think that would be the the primary reason someone I'm working on some situations now that exist because of ignorance right um one of the challenges is that uh in certain circumstances um it comes to pass that cultures crash into one another and then uh while the cultures are crashing into each other perhaps a point of conversation or an email or a decision not to participate in media um can happen and then what happens is someone ends up being the scapegoat for an entire series of decisions related to legislation or uh legal issues or whatever and so that is an element of what is happening to someone that I'm working for at the moment and what I would say is if I had come in at the beginning if I come into your story before it's a public problem we tell an incredibly different story that is best suited to your situation than if I I come into an emergency because you're already in the media uh we have a situation where the horse is out of the barn we put the horse back in the barn to some extent but you know he's gone out and he's so does wild oats and all sorts of things come from that and so we can't if I am with you from the beginning of your narrative um I'm all about putting you in a great position if I am with you from the emergency I can reposition you to the best of my ability uh but we may end up in a different place than we would have um and but but but you're dealing with a lot of successful people right and successful people to a degree are arrogant and so why would I on earth think I need you to start with when everything I got going in the world is good and and then all of a sudden when it's not going good then I'm like uh-oh I need a little help here and I would imagine that's probably as more common than anything one of my favorite questions to ask my various robots because I'm like I do use AI I do all that stuff um is how do I sell for a crisis communications problem and it always tells you to hire a crisis communications person and I'm like job security but I'm also I'm also like one of the things AI can't do is it can't measure emotional response to certain circumstances and anything to do with the human experience so reproduction consumption um life death things like that accidental death overdoses um anything that has to do with negative human experiences is incredibly sensitive and when we deal with those cases and we deal with those challenges um the way that the internet responds the way that the humans on the internet respond um can be wildly troublesome uh because it isn't what you planned for or intended it may be a a misinterpretation of the reason that you went out there in the first place um and then it snowballs right you have that and then snowballs and so I have I have three different I have a a worksheet we go through when you start your crisis comms in this case for example there is someone who got caught and that person who got caught is smarter than the other people in a way and they were willing to sacrifice everybody else so that their when they got caught it seemed like they're one of a bajillion and they're not one of a bajillion they're one of a very small group of people who want to spend a lot of money on a very ethically challenged thing um and if my client had done marketing and comms and PR and had been really careful and appropriate about it before now. Well, my client wouldn't be the scapegoat. Right? But because they hadn't because they last lacked sophistication in their English language marketing situation, um they're having a big problem. And it's an expensive problem, but it's also um one of these things cuz as they said, these sort of human experience problems are are bigger and meatier on the internet. Um they're also personally being held accountable for things that were professional decisions that were made by a group of people who run a business. Right? So, You know, we're we're in a society where we love to put people on a pedestal basically because story-driven, you know, little excerpts get them up there pretty fast, you know, and and then the thing we like even better is to tear them down off that pedestal and to uh shame them if possible because nobody wants somebody successful because it makes me feel like I'm not successful. I mean, it's a crazy world of crazy emotions going on. And and that person who takes the blame does not necessarily anything to do with if he should have taken or she should have taken the blame. It's just they were the perfect person that the pansy that was set in place, right, to to take it. So, it's interesting. I got one one more and I'll let you run, but I definitely want to stay in touch with you. Um but um my question now for you is um you've got all these different clients coming at you. So, you have to decide how to handle each situation, which is is that the fun part? Like do you rather would you rather take on a crisis um because it's just a challenge? So, my husband is a doctor, right? And um he always says I would be in ER in the ER. Uh and I I would be completely unable to do what he does. He's a cardiac anesthesiologist. He specializes in heart bypass surgery. It's in his thing is super precise and to me incredibly tedious and repetitive. And you just fiddle with knobs and you like whatever. And then they're on bypass for an hour and then you take them off bypass and hopefully they're still alive. Right? Like to him really exciting. To me, I'm like so you just one one human for the whole day. Um and I am I am a person of uh volume. Uh I like having a lot of things going on. Um I I enjoy the overdose. I was also one of those kids at school where I was understimulated unless I had too many classes and too much stuff to do. So, like I was happiest with like 35 course hours and a varsity sport. But the other thing is as a journalist, like all of my training was to be able to juggle 15 storylines simultaneously. And the the decline of journalism, the decline of American traditional journalism is such that not only are a whole bunch of us out here wanting the streets trying to figure out what else to do with our lives, but we are all um high-octane people. We're all people who really really want to be out there in the mix making the most of stuff. Um and the only way that we can do that now is is through uh all of these media channels and running group projects because it is really really different than when I first started when there were, you know, traditional newsrooms where everyone is in the same room screaming at each other and we're all somehow putting out a newspaper. Like we don't get to do that anymore. And so repeat making that experience um is difficult. I also like the best part of broadcast television and radio for me were always live um because it's it is the most fraught um and most complicated thing that you could possibly do. And uh I think that's that's the reason my husband likes cardiac bypass and that's the reason that I like uh I would love to do TV production again. But uh we don't make things those that way anymore, so I make my own trouble. Um and I also help a lot of people hopefully um try to get through Yeah, and it's it they're really I it you have to step back, but I I think that, you know, it's like seeking water seeks its own level. So, we see ourselves going in these extremes and right now things are changing so fast. I mean, everything is different, you know, how information comes to us, the amount of information, the amount of people. So, from from your standpoint, how optimistic are you um that we can figure out all these problems so that uh uh people will be able to uh at some point digest what journalism used to bring to them. Uh now it's in a different fashion. You know what? I So I was just working through Unga, the United Nations General Assembly week, which is also climate week uh here in New York. And I think that we all have to be some version of optimistic to to continue going on. I think that we're in probably the weirdest financial position a generation has ever been in. It's crazy. It doesn't make any sense. Um I think that the AI situation is interesting. I keep coming back to, okay, so we've offloaded all of the boring stuff. What do the humans do um on a daily basis? Yeah, that's true too. Yeah, what are we going to have left? Exactly. But also um and this is a more environmental thing, like we're going to shift to some extent shift back to something of a barter economy to for some of us because okay, it's really really hard to make 100 US dollars, but it's not that hard to grow a chicken if you know how to do it. And uh if you have a skill or a trade, you have something that the AI robots physically cannot do. And even if we put the robots together, the chickens aren't necessarily going to come out better. Um so so there's that. AI as a content creator I think is um is not the best. Right? But it's an organizer and it's uh you know It's a fantastic organizer. It's fantastic at discrete tasks. Um I hate the writing um and my AI's and it and it's also kind of maddening because the guys who make this apparently just hated high school uh writing classes and therefore made a robot that would do it for them. And I don't you know, I think that that disallows the whole generation of people who really really like writing and like the English language and really and and any other written language and really just are classical novelists and things like that. So you know Yeah, it kind of sucks when you went through all that work to get the skills and now everybody's cheating and getting around it, right? I mean that's part of it. It's frustrating. It's also frustrating because I think that the the aura of anti-intellectualism that we have now is going to continue to limit um human creativity. And so there are people who are being indoctrinated that education and the pursuit of knowledge and all that stuff is kind of bad. Um and I don't think But nothing's new, right? This is this is not something that hasn't and it's always about the human um trait, you know? And our trait is, you know, we are greedy people by nature and we um you know, that's that's that so you have to overcome that. Um but there's enough people out there that can pull together and the few can create a lot of havoc for the many uh especially if the many stop listening and stop uh understanding what's happening on the planet. And it's too much to process for most people I think. So It's crazy. There's a good environmental book, speaking of books, um by Ayana Elizabeth Johnson called What If We Get It Right? Um and I very much like Ayana's thesis in that book. She managed to to get out there and and really go around talking about this stuff. And her fixation is she's uh one of the only black Harvard trained marine biologists. Um and her whole hypothesis is on read vitalization of the uh global ocean. And she thinks that it's possible um that we will have some adjustment but that we could have collective action that would yield uh results. Um another good one right now is a is a sort of grassroots called uh Project Dandelion which is spin-off of Ted Countdown. Um and they're also trying to do a collective women-led group of people to have to effect environmental change. Um but you know, overall I think every time one of the world's biggest billionaires or rich people just says that they're going to go stomp off and and change and fix the ocean, I'm like I don't know that that's possible to do without a geographic limitation at very least. Yeah, the geo fixes are a little bit scary. There's no question. It's crazy. But I I think really that what we're running into is we have to have some positivity otherwise I don't know why you would continue to exist or why you'd continue to to tilt windmill is. Um, but it's it's it's a really interesting time and and I hope that people want education. Um, and I hope that people want sort of a future um that involves blue skies and and clean air, to say the least. A lot of what our efforts are is somewhat futile, but what what are our choices? You know, that I think that's the the the big thing is is, you know, every day you get up and you just put on the battle and you keep it going. So, but hey, I I really appreciate you here and I took an entire hour of your time. I appreciate that. Uh, we will stay in touch for sure. Hey, I appreciate you being here today. We'll put um all your website stuff and everything on on this thing. Uh, what I wish for you is that you keep getting interesting projects that keep you fulfilled. How is that? That's uh that's that's the best wish I can give to anyone, especially with the knowing your your nature. I think that uh I hope that have you uh on again. I have a I have a whole group of uh explorers doing all sorts of crazy things. If you're interested in any of them, let me know. All right. Thank you again. I'll be in touch. Thank you for joining the Harvesting Wisdom podcast. Click subscribe and like for ongoing insightful conversations. Explore our webpage for show notes and additional resources. Visit our guest's webpage for deeper insights. Your engagement is the foundation of our journey, and until next time, keep pursuing wisdom.