The Interpersonal Approach to Crisis PR with Kate Gardiner (Ep. 228)

Show
PR 360 (Global Results Communications)
Host
Todd Defren
Air date

This is an unedited transcript and may contain errors.

Welcome to PR 360 where every week the brightest minds in public relations, communications, and media discuss the topics and trends you need to know about. PR 360 was produced in partnership with Global Results Communications. Now here's your host, Todd Defren. Hello everybody and welcome back to the PR 360 podcast. My guest today is Kate Gardiner, the CEO and founder of Grey Horse, a full-service communications agency often behind the scenes of global crises. An industry veteran, Kate started out her career in journalism and audience engagement, triaging social media for global-facing campaigns, including award-winning coverage of the BP oil spill, the Arab Spring, Showtime's Years of Living Dangerously, Hurricane Sandy, the launch of Newsweek's print magazine, and Newsweek International. She also supported more than a dozen women at the heart of the Me Too movement. So, uh Kate, is there anything that I've missed? No, you know, we've we've been around for a while and we've gotten to do some great things, but uh thanks so much for having me. No problem. Uh I guess Grey Horse is named after your lifetime love of equestrian? Grey Horse is named after Copenhagen the horse, uh who as of this January is 34 years old. Um so yes, he's been around. He is our avatar in many circumstances. Uh he's a great great old man. He has no teeth, but he's avid participant in pasture politics, so. Well then, how do you feed him an apple if he hasn't? Uh he doesn't he doesn't do apples. He does uh horse milkshakes, um which are really gross, but he enjoys them, so. What is in a horse milkshake? Uh it is um delightful mixture of like alfalfa soup uh pellets and uh corn oil, uh which is really it's too much for me, but he really seems to enjoy it these days, so. That sounds like something, you know, when an actor is going to play a role and they have to like beef up or something, like you know, Robert De Niro in Raging Bull has to gain 60 lb. That sounds like the kind of thing that you'd sit and drink and ingest in order to get up to your uh acting weight, you know? Uh well, he was down uh during the teeth incident of 2023, he was down about oh a couple hundred pounds, and so then he started having horse essentially horse ensure, which is the is the slurry that he eats. Uh and he's back in his fighting weight last I saw him. He lives with my parents outside of Chicago, so I only see him on special occasions, but uh we'll see. I'll spend a lot of time with him this summer, so that'll be good. Very cool. Uh so over at Grey Horse, I was perusing your website and I found something that was interesting, and it was that uh your crisis communications team goes quote beyond damage control when handling a crisis. Uh can you explain how you go the extra mile above what a normal group would do? Yeah, so from depending on the circumstances, uh we've done everything from provides therapeutic services, backing people up in in mental health crises that were perpetuated by a media event, uh to really thinking about the business strategy of a comeback. So like what is going to be reasonable uh for an individual or group that has been affected by a particular crisis or adventure. Um all of these things change on a pretty regular basis, but we've had clients who've had uh all sorts of reactions financially, personally, professionally to um what has befallen them, and we've tried to figure out ways to solve those problems or at least limit the ramifications of them uh throughout the course of an engagement. Um we work with people for everything from a couple months to a couple years um depending on how the crisis works out, and uh we also try really hard to be considerate of the individual's mental health needs, uh particularly if they're a creative who's found themselves uh in a negative spotlight because uh creative work uh comes from the soul, so to speak, and the soul needs to be healthy to to be successful. Wow, so it seems to me like this is like a holistic approach um to a crisis and okay let's think about it now here here's how I'm processing this you tell me if I'm wrong let's say I was uh a I don't know a normal person who got whipped up into some kind of political crisis or something you know sometimes normal everyday people catch catch a stray bullet in uh the the things that go on and ends up finding themselves in the public spotlight I don't know like a Joe the Plumber type of guy or whatever and you find yourself in the public spotlight and then uh we I I contact Grey Horse and then you help me kind of holistically deal with the the the pressures of having to be in the lime light and and uh and that whole experience. That is absolutely what we do and sometimes I'll get um perhaps some more immediately concerning situation um a good example is we had a woman who's in real estate in Southern California she got into a battle on PTA and had to try to figure out a pathway uh that made it so she's comfortable uh continuing her role on the PTA and and in her neighborhood and all that stuff um but also those local adventures are often the most impactful personally because it's people who live directly adjacent to you it isn't necessarily anonymous people uh you know Sally May down the street very well and you have thoughts about her um but you're also kind of stuck in your school district or your neighborhood or or your community and you want to come up with with a way to move forward um and so we look at the messaging and things like that but we also look at those interpersonal relationships and how they might be leveraged or adjusted uh to cater to a circumstance and and figure out what is viable going forward uh in her case you know heartfelt apology went a long way um as did a little bit of remuneration for the scenario there was some property damage involved but uh also um really understanding that going forward the relationship would be very different and understanding the limitations that were laid out in that in that relationship would be uh the best interest of both parties. So what are some specific types of local crises that you've had to had to deal with? Local crises are everything from a tree fell down in the forest and landed on my house uh to uh much more dramatic city and state level politics uh scenarios where two folks related to one another in some way have uh strong opinions about how the future shoulds uh be and uh we've been interceded there uh there was a local level local element to a national level crisis uh back uh in the Midwest and uh figuring out a pathway forward that that limited the amount of media exposure to the circumstance while folks figured out um what the future might hold uh for the perpetrators uh was was a key component uh of that one it's really hard to talk around those NDAs. Um but you know on on a on a level it's usually a personal um it's sometimes relationships issues um and then sometimes it also has professional ramifications depending on what all the principals do uh I think that that's another key component here is is legitimately like legitimately like what do individual humans uh need from the scenario and and how do we talk them down to something that might be more reasonable uh an example yesterday there's a longstanding battle between two former co-founders who happen to live in the same town um they really don't like each other they have been sending long nasty emails uh I was like well what if you just stop sending the email and she's like I didn't think of that. So I you know forgive me if I sound a little uh I don't know uh goofy here but I I love the idea uh obviously people having problems is is bad but it's great that they have people like you to help make them better I was like this to me sounds like the greatest Netflix show of the the crisis team that comes in and specifically deals with kind of local things or something you'd see in the news like you you would mirror a news story about a PTA situation or you know somebody going viral for doing something really inappropriate publicly whatever and it's your job to come in and work with this person. I I think that there's Netflix potential here. Uh and we'll call it Grey Horse. And people like, whoa. Um yeah, it it's uh uh in some ways I think it's it's it's a show. In other ways, uh it's just sort of tilting at windmills because at the end of the day, interpersonal conflict is what it is. Um and on a local level, Yeah. uh it's more memorable perhaps because you keep running to Susie at the at the coffee shop uh for years afterwards. And you always remember how uh your high school bully feels um and how you feel about her. Um but um Yeah. Yeah. rarely are those things at a national scale. I I will say every once in a while it's it's the tea is just too robust uh to not be a national story. I think we all see that stuff on TikTok here and there. Um Yeah. Mhm. and it's it's it's sometimes you're just like, wow, that's really creative. If only they had put that much effort into something else. Yeah. So what Yeah. What What is the normal the number one type of I think mental health issue that comes with people who are dealing with these situations? Self-harm. Um to a fault. And there's either physical anger sort of things where, you know, they want to punch a brick wall until the feelings go away or um Really? Yeah. for those who are more internal focused and take ownership of it, the one of the main conundrums is is absolutely that they feel like they should cease to exist uh in some fashion. Um there's also a lot of um remonstration um particularly when we're working on sexual assault cases where um particularly women are told or feel that they shouldn't uh have been there Mhm. or that it's their fault. And very often it is not their fault. And sexual assault is never your fault, but Yeah. uh they have the perception that it is their fault because um someone said that. And sometimes the person who said it is the cops. Sometimes it's a significant other. Um and sometimes it's someone completely different. But in all of those circumstances, like finding a way to help the person who's really out here thinking that they no longer deserve to exist because of an uh an extraneous force or an external force um is is the number one point uh that we find ourselves at. And a lot of the time uh intimate partners, you know, family, friends around the individual um are trying to intercede, but they really can't because a lot of the challenges are coming from within the individual, and they're not always obvious uh until it's too late or until it's it's really really really distressing. Um and in certain circumstances, we've done everything from bring in help, uh so psychiatrists, therapists, bodyguards, things like that. Um and then we have also gone out of our way to um be kind and courteous and careful with the principal um to help him or her um re-engage with the world around them and find uh some sort of holistic path forward for themselves, for their organization, or around the circumstances at the center of the scenario. And you know. Uh what are some ways that you uh helped uh people get through the Me Too movement? Uh Yeah, so we've we've worked with a lot of women uh in litigation, uh not only for Me Too, but often for instances of workplace sexual harassment, instances of uh stranger danger, instances of um bad touch. Uh and we've also worked with individuals who find themselves being critiqued online um and who are particularly sensitive to that. Um the first thing that we do is we assess physical safety. Is the person physically safe uh in the scenarios they're in? Um do they need physical assistance? They need to go to a hospital? Do they need to do a rape kit? Do they need to do any sort of assessment of immediate damages? Um the second element is digital security. Is their bank account, is their financial situation online secure? And then is there a digital persona, their Facebook, their Twitter, their Instagram? Uh is that all locked down and um protected? Uh real quick. So so is it often that people if they're involved in some kind of um sexual harassment thing uh They can be financially victimized after that? Uh sometimes. It depends on how on the tactics of the other party. Wow. Jeez. Um So So they'll they'll like go after They'll try to find a way to steal money like like we don't want you to hire a lawyer so we're going to like figure out a way to rob you or something. Does that happen? They will cripple them. Uh the what has happened historically is a prominent individual files um or alleges in public something having happened. Um and then magically or mystically uh people from the internet or assuming who we assume are from the internet uh will try to break into say their bank account or distribute their social security number or do things like that um through the process that's known as doxxing. And then uh really what we're trying to do is mitigate the results of that. Um one of the common problems is someone uses the same password for their Twitter that they use for their bank account for example. And by sheer guessing um it inhibits their access to capital. Um either short-term capital, you know, the 500 bucks you keep in your emergency account or longer-term capital. They figure out a way into um your larger financial accounts for and really try to play dirty. This is typically a tactic that we see in higher stakes scenarios. Um but it's definitely something that that folks have been really creative about. Um and uh we just always assess it now because the times that we don't uh we live to regret it. And and I'm very conservative uh on that front. I prefer to have gone through this checklist of tactics and say oh you know what we've all changed it to 26 key word a letter encrypted password like we're magical move forward with that. Um then see we'll regret having done that assessment uh in a crisis situation and then find ourselves holding the bag um with a client who who, you know, is is forced to deal with with elements of identity theft or or fraud in addition to uh the precipitating incident which is often sexual harassment um or sexual assault. I would think that if I was a victim of, you know, sexual assault or any any type of like scenario you've been talking about and I came to you, I would feel a tremendous feeling of relief because uh you know obviously when you're in a situation like that you have no idea what's coming at you. You have no idea where it's going to come from. And finding somebody who understands and has been there before with with clients I think would be a tremendous relief in in a in a crisis. For some clients that is the the read we get. Um that you either feel relief or you're angry that you have to hire us. Um Right. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well it's you know it's like you know it's like when the IRS comes after you and you have to call the the tax guy, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's it's an interesting thing. It depends on what your natural reaction uh to uh stressful circumstances is. Uh some for some folks it's anger which is reasonable to be honest. Um and for other folks it's action. It's how do I get out of this or how do I fix it. Um and then for other folks it's like what do I get out of it. Um and we try to to manage all of those expectations as much as we like to uh really ensure that you're going to have you're the consequences are are mitigated. But you know I it it really really depends on the individual um and also on their attorney. Uh we are typically hired by litigators. We are hired by accountants. We're hired by managers, business managers, um people like that. Uh people with invested interest in the success and safety of the principal. Um and uh we're very very aware that hopefully everyone's motivations are aligned or similar um in circumstances like these. But also they don't they aren't always. Um and I prefer to believe that my responsibility is to the principal. Um but sometimes depending on who's who's hired us or who is, you know, the most financially motivated in the circumstance it could be that um ultimately the situation uh particularly employment will result in the principal's termination personally or uh into significant lifestyle changes for that person as they deal with the consequences of something around them. Um and it really depends if they were the victim of something um or if they're under attack uh for other reasons. And so it it it it all I can say is it depends, but hopefully everybody involved has the best interests in at heart of the victim. Um and ultimately they want to advocate for changes and for results for that person. Uh that isn't always the case, but that's what what we prefer to believe. Um and I'll be one of the one of the agencies that won't work for the bad guys. Um and so if you if you committed sexual assault or physical violence against women in particular, you're you're kind of out. Um and we won't we won't help you. Um but uh it it really just kind of depends. Um you know, this kind of work is is difficult and we like to do sometimes like we'll take a little baby scandal um that is has no particular losers or winners um as as something of a palate cleanser because you can't you can't talk to someone about their systemic uh issues of violence um all the time and then have any sense of humor or or really enjoy any element of the job. So um but it really just kind of depends. I mean, we do this we do a lot of different things. Um and I, you know, I honestly do love doing um things that that advance the cause of women, put more women in the workplace, and stand up in support of women in their rights. I also uh am happy to help use incidents that occur um as a pathway forward uh for uh organizations to adjust their policies and their expectations um in a way that that facilitates better and more transparent uh work environments for for groups of people that are that are collaborating. So it it all just kind of depends. It's not all crisis all the time, but uh my attitude towards crisis seems to be a bit different uh from many other organizations and and um you know, my team and I are really happy to be able to do that. It's a luxury. Uh that's why we're so small. But uh but we enjoy the work and and, you know, we do help people make their worlds a better place, all things considered. Well, okay. Uh we're coming up towards the end. I But I was really interested in how you transitioned from working, you know, in in kind of like a journalistic space and then into the the crisis management. Uh how did how did you leap from one to the other and is there a through line? Yeah, the through line is uh actually that I worked in um high stakes media environment. Uh I attracted disaster every time I went to a new job. There would immediately be some sort of like global disaster. Um it was it is something that continues to happen. Uh every year or two there's some sort of global thing and we just happened to be immediately adjacent to it. Um and uh that's how my whole journalism career was. So when I started really leaning into comms, uh we were able to both attract clients that were active at a global level, but also um really reflect the time. Um so reflect the the social movements of the time um and the desires of the millennial and Gen Z generations um in the internet and and looking forward. I think my curiosity will be uh how global movements uh happen in the next 20 years because I think that that every tool that that I've worked with in the past little while has has dramatically changed and the expectations and relationship with the economy of media uh is also very different. You know, I I grew up wanting desperately to to live my best life as like as Girl Friday or any Woman of the Year or any of the old Katherine Hepburn as journalist movies. Um and those roles don't really exist anymore uh for lack of business model. Um so hopefully is going to fix journalism and we can take and all tell stories the old fashioned way, but until then, uh you know, crisis comes and in general public relations for good is is something that's absolutely worth doing and and changing models so that it involve everybody from influencers to tiny Tim on Twitter is is really a key component to the future of this industry and the way that we as communications professionals can kind of go forward. Um I think one of the things that's challenging about those of us who want to tell stories for a living is there are very few opportunities to do so. Yeah. Um and uh a lot of the things that do happen are are based off of serendipity uh rather than strategy. Well, thank you so much Kate for showing up on PR 360. Uh how do people follow you? What's the call to action here? How do they get involved? What's happening? Yeah, get in touch with me uh we're Grey Horse.com, Grey Horse with an EY um and really easy to find online. I'm always happy uh to talk to folks, bounce ideas. Um I'm a queen of Zoom. I'll be on Zoom for the rest of today and for the rest of infinity. Uh I'm based between New York, Miami, and Chicago, so I'm also always friendly for a coffee. Awesome. Well, thank you so much Kate and best of luck and wishes to Copenhagen. I'm excited to see him next week. We're spending Memorial Day together. Uh but nice to meet you and uh thanks for having me on. Thank you. PR 360 was produced by Todd Perry in partnership with Global Results Communications. Be sure to subscribe to the show and leave a review wherever you get podcasts. Follow GRC on all socials at Global Results. Follow Todd on Twitter at ToddAPerry. That's Todd with one D. Talk to you next week.